Virgins Don’t Exist

When I was in high school, I had a classmate who claimed that virgins don’t exist.

My first thought when I first heard him declare ‘Virgin’s Don’t Exist’ was ‘Excuse me, I am a virgin” (I didn’t say this out loud, I just said it in my head).

But as I got to know him and his life philosophy better, I understood that he was critiquing the idea of virginity itself.

He didn’t mean that there weren’t people who had never had sex. That would have been ridiculous. What he meant is that people who have had sex are not fundamentally different from people who have not had sex, therefore the concept of virginity should not exist.

And the more I think about ‘virginity’, the more messed up I think the idea is. In every culture that I am familiar with, the notions of ‘virginity’ and ‘chastity’ are based on some really messed-up ideas.

(Trigger warning for this paragraph only: potential fictional sexual assault)

For example, in Mandarin there is a word (thankfully old-fashioned and rare, but it is still used), ‘zhēnliè’. When I encountered this word in a novel, some characters were claiming that a certain female character was not zhēnliè because she let her kidnappers have sex with her instead of committing suicide (actually, her kidnappers did not have sex with her, but that is beside the point). I think it is incredibly messed up that women would be expected to prevent being raped by committing suicide, and that if they prefer being raped to dying, they are somehow bad people or responsible for the situation (which is what these characters were implying).

Thankfully, there is no word for zhēnliè in English (though I must point out that there are respects in which Mandarin is a much less sexist language than English).

I know ideas about virginity and chastity are changing (for example, in the past, the word ‘virgin’ could only apply to females). But even today, it is still a) tied to the assumption that almost everybody should have sex (losing one’s virginity is supposed to be an important event in one’s life), b) that certain kinds of sex are illicit, and the criteria are not based on rational things like consent and power (im)balances, and c) slut-shaming (which feeds into rape culture).

While I suppose it is technically possible to adapt the idea of virginity into something that is not sexist, not supportive of rape culture, and inclusive of asexuals … why bother? Would a gender-equal culture, based on mutual respect and inclusive of the full range of sexual and gender diversity, really need the concept? Couldn’t we just say that somebody has little or no sexual experience, and leave it at that?

I’d rather just throw the idea of virginity in the trash.

Which makes me wonder how I’d answer if somebody asked ‘Are you a virgin?’ I could reply ‘none of your business’, but I might say ‘no, but I’ve never had sex’.

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “Virgins Don’t Exist

  1. Well said…I don’t think there’s any way in which the concept of “virginity” helps us. It just creates a lot of pressure for people to have sex. When I reached the age of 20 or so, suddenly all my friends who were sexually inexperienced wanted to have sex, because they thought no one would want to date a virgin. And yeah, some people think dating a virgin is “too much pressure”, but those aren’t good people to date, I’d think. And it shows how much people have internalized these stupid virgin ideas.

    • Heh, when I was 18-20 years old, my favorite way to deal with this kind of pressure was to make jokes about virginity. It was a way to publicly reject the notion that everyone wants to/should ‘lose their virginity’ that wasn’t awkward.

  2. Pingback: An Analogy about Abstinence | The Notes Which Do Not Fit

  3. Pingback: Coming of Age without Sex? | The Notes Which Do Not Fit

  4. “I think it is incredibly messed up that women would be expected to prevent being raped by committing suicide, and that if they prefer being raped to dying, they are somehow bad people or responsible for the situation (which is what these characters were implying).”

    Commiting suicide doesn’t prevent rapes. Unless you consider silence equals consent, and dead people are always silent, so they always consent. Because people still can have sex with corpses. Or, if you consider a corpse is not a person anymore, in this case, an object can’t be raped.

  5. Pingback: An Asexual Virginity (or Lack Thereof?) – From Fandom to Family: Sharing my many thoughts

  6. I really believe that I would prefer death to rape. And I just would like not to be called a mad person because of my view.

    • You are entitled to your own preferences, but this post does not criticise people who make the choice *for themselves* to die rather than face rape, let alone call them ‘mad’. It criticizes people who decided *for others* whether it better to commit suicide or risk rape, and those who shame women because they did not commit suicide before rape. For example, in the novel mentioned in this post, the character is question is ostracized from her family because she refused to commit suicide, and thus she has to leave and go live in the wilderness. If you think shaming people that way is okay…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.